Reason, the Good and Rights

Home Writing Politics Vita Teaching

 

 

Marc Stier

ANALYTICAL TABLE OF CONTENTS

 PREFACE vii

A NOTE ON TERMINOLOGY xxxvii

ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS xli

PART ONE CHALLENGES FOR LIBERAL
POLITICAL PHILOSOPHY 1

CHAPTER ONE THE TROUBLE WITH LIBERALISM 2

§1. Philosophies and Principles 3

§2. What is Liberalism? 6

§2. The Challenge of Liberty 9

§3. The Challenge of Democracy and Equality 14

§4. The Challenge of the Politics of the Good 16

a. Environmentalism 17

b. Feminism 19

c. Traditionalism 21

d. Civic Republicanism 24

§5. Liberalism and the Politics of the Good 28

CHAPTER TWO NATURALIST LIBERALISM 30

§6. Naturalist Metaphysics and Epistemology 32

a. Epistemological Naturalism 32

b. Metaphysical Naturalism 33

§7. Subjectivist Philosophical Psychology 36

§8. Naturalism and Liberalism 38

§9. The Denial of Substantive Rationality 41

§10. The Primacy of Instrumental Reason 42

§11. Two Versions of Naturalist Liberalism 43

§12. Civil Liberty 46

§13. The Flight from Politics 47

a. The Instrumental Conception of Politics 48

b. Liberal Morality 49

c. Politics and Markets 50

d. Technocracy 52

§14. The Failure of Naturalist Liberalism: Rights 54

§15. The Failure of Naturalist Liberalism: The Good 59

CHAPTER THREE HISTORICIST LIBERALISM 62

§16. The Failure of Naturalism and the Turn to Philosophical Historicism 62

§17. Interpretavist Philosophical Psychology 66

§18. Historicist Liberalism 70

§19. The Limits of Historicist Liberalism: Rights 72

§20. The Limits of Historicist Liberalism: The Good 78

CHAPTER FOUR PERFECTIONIST LIBERALISM 85

§21. Varieties of Perfectionism 86

a. Anti-Perfectionism and the Liberalism of Fear 87

b. Minimal Perfectionism 89

c. Perfectionism and Autonomy 90

§22. Justifying a Conception of the Good 92

§23. The Limits of Perfectionism: Liberty 94

§24. The Limits of Perfectionism: Distributive Justice 97

§25. The Limits of Perfectionism: Perfectionism and the Common Good 100

CHAPTER FIVE POLITICAL LIBERALISM 102

§26. The Aims of Political Liberalism 104

§27. Ground Floor or Second Story Political Liberalism? 108

a. Problems on the Second Story 110

b. Problems on the Ground Floor 113

§28. Inclusive or Exclusive Political Liberalism? 119

§29. Political Liberalism and the Possibility of Moral Discovery 124

PART TWO REASON AND THE HUMAN GOOD` 128

CHAPTER SIX DILEMMAS OF CONTEMOPRARY PHILOSOPHICAL PSYCHOLOGY

§30. Problems for Subjectivism and Interpretavism I:
Phenomena of Individual Life 131

§31. Problems for Subjectivism and Interpretavism II:
Phenomena of Political and Social Life 138

CHAPTER SEVEN WANTS AND DESIRES 148

§32. Wants and Desires: The Basic Distinction 149

§33. Desires, Wants and Emotions 154

§34. Reflection and The Articulation of Wants 159

§35. Emotions and Human Fulfillment: A First Look 171

§36. Phenomena of Individual and Political and Social Life Revisited 175

a. Uncertainty and Mistakes About Our Ends 176

b. Self-deception 177

c. Weakness of Will 183

§37. Human Nature and Explanation and
the Phenomena of Political and Social Life 186

CHAPTER EIGHT HUMAN WANTS AND
THE HUMAN GOOD 189

§38. Reflection and Substantive Rationality 189

§39. The Role of a Conception of Human Nature 192

§40. The Relative Importance of Our Desires and Wants 196

§41. The Satisfaction of Human Wants: Pessimistic Perspectives 199

§42. The Satisfaction of Human Wants: Optimistic Perspectives 200

§43. Critical Interpretavism and Plato's Republic 205

CHAPTER NINE INDIVIDUAL AND COMMON GOOD 212

§44. The Good Polity and Society and Distributive Justice 212

§45. The Importance of Political and Social Theory 215

§46. Political Theory and the Human Good:
The Articulation of Wants and Individual and Communal Fulfillment 219

§47. The Human Good and Our Good 224

§48. The Virtues 228

CHAPTER TEN THEORY AND PRACTICE 231

§49. The Independence of Practice 231

§50. Technical, Interpretative, and Educative Uses of Political and Social Theory 234

§51. The Preconditions of Educative Transformation 240

§52. Technical Uses of Theory in the Service of Educative Political and Social Transformation 245

§53. Political Theory and Tyranny 248

PART THREE PRAGMATIC RATIONALISM AND POLITICS 251

CHAPTER ELEVEN RATIONALITY 252

§54. A Pragmatic View of Rationality 252

§55. The Aims of Rational Inquiry 257

§56. Ideal Rationality 264

§57. The Formal Aspect of Ideal Rationality 279

§58. Truth 284

CHAPTER TWELVE RATIONALITY AND RIGHTS 296

§59. Do We Need an Independent Defense of Rights? 296

§60. The Presupposition of Rationality in Politics 299

§61. The Limits of Rationality in Politics 302

§62. Formal Rationality and Political Philosophy 308

a. Universalization 309

b. The Categorical Imperative Proposal 312

c. The Consent Proposal 319

§63. An Outline of the Principles of Political Right 330

CHAPTER THIRTEEN THE CHOICE OF
POLITICAL INSTITUTIONS 336

§64. Consent 336

§65. Critical Interpretavism and the Theory of Political Right. 346

§66. Republican Government 349

§67. Dimensions of Political Inequality 354

a. Majoritarianism and Pluralism 355

b. Elitism, Populism and Participatory Democracy 360

c. Social Inequality and Democracy 368

d. Structural Inequality and Democracy 370

e. Educational Inequality and Democracy 387

§68. Rationality—Formal and Substantive—and Political Inequality 388

a. Substantive Rationality and the Choice of a Form of Government 390

b. The Problem of Social Inequality 400

c. Is Democracy Always Required? 403

§69. Consent and Corporations 404

§70. Neutrality, Compromise and Subsidiarity 407

CHAPTER FOURTEEN CIVIL LIBERTY 417

§71. Why Civil Liberty I?: Rational Argument and the Good 417

§72. Why Civil Liberty II?: Impartiality and the Reconstructed Original Position 422

§73. The Limits of Civil Liberty 432

§74. What Civil Liberty Does and Does Not Require 443

§75. The Claims of Religion 447

CHAPTER FIFTEEN JUSTICE 452

§76. Equality of Opportunity 452

§77. Justice and the Good 464

§78. Desert 471

§79. The Difference Principle 475

a. From the Good to the Difference Principle 475

b. The Difference Principle, Substantive Rationality and Neutrality 477

c. The Difference Principle and Natural Talents 479

d. The Difference Principle and Ambition 485

e. Grounds for the Difference Principle in Pragmatic Rationalism 493

§80. Justice, Equity and Care 499

CHAPTER SIXTEEN RATIONALITY AND MORALITY 517

§81. Why Do the Right Thing? 517

CONCLUSION THE RIGHT AND THE GOOD 529

§82. Aspirations to the Right and the Good 529

§83. Are The Right and the Good Compatible? 537

ENDNOTES 553

BIBLIOGRAPHY 655

Books in Progress

Home | Teaching | Writing | Vita